in

Sauer Reviews

Pop Culture

Sauer Reviews

The New Star Wars DVDs: To Buy or Not to Buy?

    Dammit Lucas!!!. When Lucas released the Star Wars Trilogy on DVD a few years back, he made it VERY clear, that he would never release the original films. Stating that the new "revised versions" were the "real" versions of the film. Fanboys complained, but eventually got over it. Then two years later Lucas announced that the original films would finally be released on DVD. Of course, this shows just how EVIL Lucas is. Considering the new re-releases contain both the 2004 edition and the originals. Many fans I know already have multiple sets of the original SW wars trilogy (I have bought 4 total in my lifetime). So NOW after Lucas has already won our money, he decides to release these films as the fans wanted them in the first place. The NERVE!!. It gets worse, the original films are nothing more then the 1994 remasters. So what is a die-hard Star Wars fan to do? Let's go through the Pros and Cons

Pros:

- Greedo shoots first

- No awful Jabba tail stepping

- No CG filled Mos Eisley

- "La Petnik" original Jabba Palace song

- "Yub Nub" original Ewok song

- original Jedi ending

CONS:

No ENHANCED WIDESCREEN!!

No Surround Sound!!!

VHS Picture Quality!!!!!!!!

No BOX SET!!, each film will have to be purchased seperately. Which means this will cost more $$$ then the original release!!

So as you can see, the fans may finally be getting the originals they deserve, but at the cost of a lackluster experience. This is just so lazy and greedy of Lucas. He knows the super fans will buy this regardless. So what's a fanboy to do? Sadly, I'm extremely tempted to buy these regardless. My biggest fear isn't getting a lackluster performance, it's the good chance that Lucas will re-release these AGAIN, only with an updated transfer. Who's to say he won't? It's clear Lucas will re-release these films over and over again, further draining our wallets to infinity.

So, I've made the decision NOT to buy. If I get these as a Xmas/Birthday present, well, I guess that's ok. Let someone else spend their hard earn money on these DVDs. I sure won't. I'm sure I'll be buying the HD-DVD/BluRay DVD set in the future anyway.

Share this post: Email it! | bookmark it! | digg it! | reddit!
Published Sep 13 2006, 04:55 PM by sauer
Filed under: ,

Comments

 

e. said:

not a chance at this stage in the game.  im ok with what i have and know ill be forced to purchase the next gen set. maybe ill buy it on itunes so i can watch it on my big 2incher. hardy har.

September 13, 2006 10:02 AM
 

Raul Duke said:

Aren't we over Star Wars yet? How many times can George stick a fist up our ass before we just give up? I will not be buying another version of Star Wars, no matter how hi-def or 3d or virtual reality it gets. I don't want to sully my memories any further than I already have.

Ok, maybe i'd buy a virtual reality version.

September 13, 2006 12:36 PM

Leave a Comment

(required)  
(optional)
(required)  
Add
Powered by Community Server (Non-Commercial Edition), by Telligent Systems